Hazel said:Lindy -
I think we all tend to forget what it was like in the beginning. Especially for you soapmakers who have been doing this for years and years. I was very insecure when I first started. I didn't want to waste oils so I followed recipes for my first few batches. Once I figured out kind of what I was doing, I started changing percentages to see how it changed the quality of the soap. Then I started experimenting with oils not usually used in soap, etc.
I used Anne Watson's shea soap for my first batch. My second batch was one of Sandy Maine's recipes. I also read Kathy Miller's site for the basics (thanks for the reminder Soaplady22). My first salt bar batch was Dagmar's recipe.
I also started with recipes, modifying as I gained confidence in the process and experimenting with an ever expanding variety of oils. I have come full circle, reducing the variety of oils on hand to my favorites. My focus now is more cosmetic; EO/FO, color and design.