Soap curse? Help!

[MissCherryBlossom]

Hello everyone! This is my first time posting here, but I've been quietly perusing the forum for quite a while now. I need all the feedback you guys can kindly give me.
Here's the deal; I started soaping two years ago and made about a dozen really nice batches and that was it. But now I started again and the two batches I made have failed! I'm starting to think I'm cursed or something (not really though! Haha).
I was told the first one failed because of using a somewhat clumpy lye. So I got new lye but in flakes.

Recipe: The recipe for my small Bastile batch was this: OO 68.73% , Castor 6.29% , CO (Refined) 24.98%, Water 8.26 oz, Lye 3.45 oz, Superfatted at 5%, 1tsp Sodium Lactate
Problem: The soap was doing just fine and hardening for about an hour. Then it turned to mush, literally. It's extremely oily on the top and 24 hours laters I have no hopes for it.
Question: What do you think went wrong? I thought it was the lye the first time but I changed it. I hadn't used Refined CO on my previous batches but did with this one. Could that be the culprit? Or could it be a faulty scale?

Thanks for all the help you can give me!

 

[lsg]

You give the percentages, but not the actual weights of the oils. At what temp. did you soap? You could have gotten a false trace. Put your soap in an old Crockpot, stick blend and cook. You might be able to salvage it.

 

[MissCherryBlossom]

You're right sorry, here it is: OO 17.20 oz, CO 6.25 oz, 1.58 oz
So you think it could work? Do you have any idea why it happened? Thank you!

 

[savonierre]

It could be a faulty scale for sure. I ran your recipe through SM3 and it is fine. It also could be as lsg said, the false trace. I agree with lsg to put it in a crock and fix it up.

 

[MissCherryBlossom]

For how long should I put in the crockpot? And thank you for helping me out!