Natures Garden Bay Rum

[Lynnz]

I soaped Oregon Trails Bay Rum for many years and I adore it but of late the shipping has got way too expensive so I purchased Natures Garden instead. OOB I am not as impressed but I am hoping someone will tell me it is awesome soaped

 

[HorseCreek]

I can't compare to your other one, but I soap NG'S version and it always sells well.

 

[Obsidian]

It smells worse in soap then it does OOB. I ended up selling my bottle as it was just awful and nobody I know would use the soap I made, its still in the closet.

 

[shunt2011]

I didn't care for the NG Bay Rum at all. I've been using WSP's Bay Rum and my husband loves it as do my customers, though it's not a huge seller.

 

[pamielynn]

It is not even close to WSP's - however, since I soaped it, I named it something completely different than "Bay Rum" and sold out of it. As much as I hate to, I continue to buy Bay Rum from WSP for my "Bay Rum" soap.

NG's Nantucket Briar is also not even close to WSP's - just in case you were thinking of buying that, also

 

[Lynnz]

Thanks for the help I think I shall leave it as I loved my Bay Rum and think I might just be disappointed to soap this

 

[new12soap]

I love love LOVE wsp's Bay Rum... but, be careful, the max usage rate in soap is 3.3%

 

[DWinMadison]

Another vote for WSP's bay rum. Outside of EOs its been one one of the few FOs that I really like. Ok...Roasted Coffee from WSP is great too.

 

[kmarvel]

Thanks for the help I think I shall leave it as I loved my Bay Rum and think I might just be disappointed to soap this

If you blend the Bay Rum with Lime it is a nice scent.