Browsing this thread and happy to hear everyone's "soapiness"! My upset-ness is gone and planning for soaping marathon next weekend! (Upset because someone commented that she's SOooo worried that my soap won't sell coz they look so plain she won't even buy, gosh I'm never gonna offer her any of my "gift soap" anymore...but thanks to her, I came up with more designs for my coming marathon) *feeling determined*
Snob. (And good for you. Keep her off your gift list!!) Personally, I'm a minimalist. I like plain stuff and wouldn't buy gussied up soaps for myself. (Although I did buy one that looks like a door in the middle of a "butterfly" bush. It's called "Fairy House.") However, that isn't stopping me from experimenting with micas and designs. I can't imagine I'd ever do anything really fancy; however, it's fun doing Taiwan circle swirls because I don't know what's going to be revealed. I'm not very good with hanger swirls, put they're passable.
Do what feels right/good for you and forget what anyone else thinks. I'm doing the colors and swirls to challenge myself. That's it. If I get a great looking soap, cool. If not, that's fine too. As long as it passes the zap test and is fully saponified, I win. It's soap. It will get me clean. That's all it's meant to do.