I've soaped the Explorer Series. They all soaped well. Discoloration in all but Rustic herb Table and Inlet sea
Marvel Garden turned a yellow/green mossy clor and Red resin a light Cocoa color.. the others were just slightly discolored for me.
The scent them selves are incredibly complex. They smell very very different soaped than OOB. After 2 weeks they are still morphing into different scents than the started out to be. The only one I am disappointed in is the Red resin. It started out very woodsy to me, but now is perfume/powdery.
My personal favs are AloAni, Rustic Herb, Marvel Gardens and Sweet Lodge.. wow they sweet lodge smells different each time I sniff it.