New needs help with a shaving soap recipe?

[spacetransient]

New comparisons of recipe's -shaving results.

Without going into too many details I really like what the Mango as SF did for the suds- more of the silky feel we look for and noticeably easier to lather. Adding glycerin only made subtle changes to the conditioning/slip/cushioning elements- all positive but minor except noticeably easier and more lather.

So while I like what Shea has done for my skin, as a shaving soap I like the Mango better- a -fresher, cleaner, silkier lather- and think those improvements are worthwhile even with the slight loss of conditioning which the Shea imparts and which the added glycerin helps offset too.

I'll be saving the Shea for body soaps and lotions when this project is satisfied...

While perfection is not attainable I think we can get "close enough" to feel the possibility of incremental improvements are no longer worth the added effort. The point of diminishing returns- At least that has been my experience and what I am hoping for.

I've tested a fragrance that works for me and my skin and will be added in the next batch.

A few more experiments and it's on to tallow...

I am quite interested in hearing back from Craig and Lee but I think my part in this thread should wrap for now- hopefully another begins later.:arrow: WHEN THE SEMI-FINALS BEGIN!!

Thanks all!!!:clap:

 

[The Efficacious Gentleman]

Awesome news - sounds like you are well on the way to having a recipe that delivers on all fronts.

 

[LBussy]

What is the advantage of removing water from the soap? Especially in such a labor intensive way that surely this must be if we occasionally stir like a sauce?

Once you find a way that works for you, you should stick to it. Consistent results come from consistent practice.

I arrived at that because it absolutely 100% means that the lye is reacted (probably is consistently after 30 ins). I do not believe that a hot process soap so processed benefits in any significant way from a lengthy cure, I do not perceive any difference in a months-old soap and a day old soap. Heat accelerates any chemical changes and drives off moisture (both parts of curing). Aside from waiting for the soap fairy to dose it with pixie dust after a fortnight under the moon nothing else is going to change.

It's not labor intensive really. I close the crock pot lid and stir every 20 mins or so.