I think it’s fine - I think that the intent of the challenge is to get a fresh start in 2025 by using up some soap you made that isn’t sparking joy for you, whether it be cold process, hot process, or melt and pour. The rules don’t specify so I’ll add that it’s ok to use up old melt and pour soaps.@Vicki C , I am pretty positive I know the answer, so I didn't really want to ask, but I'm going to ask anyway. I don't have any CP shreds but I have some M&P soaps that I've had for a year, don't like, and would be happy to shred up. Do the shreds have to be CP or can they be M&P?