First Scent Combo's Testing:

Soapmaking Forum

Help Support Soapmaking Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Shalisk

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 4, 2014
Messages
230
Reaction score
146
4 Combo's + Ratio, Updates when I have them (About a hour or so)
Ratio = # of toothpicks dipped.

1) Lemongrass + Cedarwood at a 2 to 1 Ratio
2) Lemongrass + 6x Sweet Orange at a 2 to 1 Ratio
3) Peppermint + Tea Tree at 1 to 2
4) Speatmint + Tea Tree at 1 to 2

I know many have done these combos im sure but figured I would post :D
 
Last edited:
1) Was alright, needed a extra toothpick of Lemongrass (3 to 1)
2) Wasn't...bad, just not my thing.
3) Really nice. Had to add a toothpick of Teatree
4) *hurk*
 
Lemongrass is in the same scent family as the orange. That is why the combo is sort of meh at best. However, I find that lemongrass plays nicely with a tiny bit of cinnamon(or cassia) bark EO, or clove bud EO. Or both. I think the contrast/combination of citrus and spice is really great.
 
Lemongrass is in the same scent family as the orange. That is why the combo is sort of meh at best. However, I find that lemongrass plays nicely with a tiny bit of cinnamon(or cassia) bark EO, or clove bud EO. Or both. I think the contrast/combination of citrus and spice is really great.

The SPearmint and Teatree was vile o.o;
I do have some clove, I might have to play with those two as well. :)
The Spearmint might just be its own thing I think. :)
 
I just used a combo of peppermint and tea tree in my HP shaving soap experiment today. It smells really nice and refreshing, but one of the things I noticed in my research is that peppermint has a relatively low flashpoint of 120 deg F (at least according to Brambleberry), so that needs to be taken into account for soaping.
 
I just used a combo of peppermint and tea tree in my HP shaving soap experiment today. It smells really nice and refreshing, but one of the things I noticed in my research is that peppermint has a relatively low flashpoint of 120 deg F (at least according to Brambleberry), so that needs to be taken into account for soaping.

New to flashpoints and such myself. So this means that I should mix at less than 120 than to prevent it from losing the scent?
 
Citrus EOs are a bear for this. 104-110F for most of them. By the time my soap (HP shaving soap) cools down near that, it's a real PITA to stir. :p
 
teatree can be so tricky and a pita all at once. the smell is so damn strong to use on its own, and if mixed it usually overpowers other scents quite easily. hate hate teatree :(

no, actually i dont hate it, just gotta be super careful with this one.. and i have too much i dont know what to do with it..
 
teatree can be so tricky and a pita all at once. the smell is so damn strong to use on its own, and if mixed it usually overpowers other scents quite easily. hate hate teatree :(

no, actually i dont hate it, just gotta be super careful with this one.. and i have too much i dont know what to do with it..

Well with this last soap I made, 1 peppermint + 3 Teatree was perfect. The soap smells awsome and the teatree is a secondary scent you get right near the middle / end of your 'sniff'
 
The SPearmint and Teatree was vile o.o;
I do have some clove, I might have to play with those two as well. :)
The Spearmint might just be its own thing I think. :)
lol I don't think I would've tried spearmint with tea tree, but I do love a tisane I made using lemongrass and spearmint. Why not try those two together?
 
I think Teatree is to scent what cilantro is to taste. You either love it or hate it. People who love it, LOVE it. People who hate it, HATE it.

I do not like Teatree in the least. To tolerate it, I have to drown it out with other scents.

(I don't like cilantro, either.)
 
I'd say patchoulli is more like the scent-cilantro than tea tree is.

(I lovelovelove cilantro, I'm on the ambivalent side of 'like' for tea tree, and one time I sniffed a patch-scented soap in the store... HATED it and the scent lingered on my hands even after going to the bathroom and washing them.)
 
I can't bear cilantro (coriander over here). :problem: I don't like patchouli on its own, but it can do great things mixed with other oils. Tea tree? I love it for my skin and I quite like the scent, but it's a kind of functional smell to me. I'd be very happy to use it for its properties, but wouldn't choose it just for its fragrance.

Maybe you could find a teenager with bad skin, Seven - it's one of the few oils you can use directly on your skin and it is very good.
 
lol belinda and shalisk :D i think u guys are gonna regret it as soon as i say that i live far far away from u guys (indonesia). had i live in the US, hey lets do biz shall we :D

anyway, shalisk, thanks for the info on tt + peppermint. am gonna try a sniff asap.
 
lol belinda and shalisk :D i think u guys are gonna regret it as soon as i say that i live far far away from u guys (indonesia). had i live in the US, hey lets do biz shall we :D

anyway, shalisk, thanks for the info on tt + peppermint. am gonna try a sniff asap.

1 Peppermint 3 Teatree (dip a toothpick same depth for each number)
 

Latest posts

Back
Top