No one in the original group of posts is active on SMF anymore. It's best to start a new thread if you want to ask a question, rather than tag your question at the end of an ancient thread. If you want, you can reference the old thread in your new post -- that can be helpful to bring others up to speed.
Any soap will work for making felted soap, including coconut oil soap and commercial soap or cleansing bars. Which type you choose depends on your goals.
If you want to make a cute little soap for a fun gift, the type of soap might not matter a bit. If you want to make felted bars for bathing while camping, you might choose a soap high in coconut for good lathering in cold, salty, or hard water. For general bathing at home, I'd use a decent bath soap that is long lasting and well cured.
For my felted bars, I normally use "seconds" from my handmade soap batches. These bars are soap that's perfectly fine, but might not look the best. Most of my recipes are formulated to be long lasting with a goodly amount of palmitic and stearic acid (lard, tallow, palm have high %'s of these fatty acids), because the people who use these bars are using them for normal bathing at home.
Felted soaps aren't everyone's cuppa tea. I make them for kids (they can't eat felted soap!) and for travel. For general use at home, I'm not much of a fan.
Any soap will work for making felted soap, including coconut oil soap and commercial soap or cleansing bars. Which type you choose depends on your goals.
If you want to make a cute little soap for a fun gift, the type of soap might not matter a bit. If you want to make felted bars for bathing while camping, you might choose a soap high in coconut for good lathering in cold, salty, or hard water. For general bathing at home, I'd use a decent bath soap that is long lasting and well cured.
For my felted bars, I normally use "seconds" from my handmade soap batches. These bars are soap that's perfectly fine, but might not look the best. Most of my recipes are formulated to be long lasting with a goodly amount of palmitic and stearic acid (lard, tallow, palm have high %'s of these fatty acids), because the people who use these bars are using them for normal bathing at home.
Felted soaps aren't everyone's cuppa tea. I make them for kids (they can't eat felted soap!) and for travel. For general use at home, I'm not much of a fan.