Dog nose and paw balm question

[BigDog]

Hello all,

Made up some Nose and Paw Balm for my dogs using a recipe from Martha Stewart’s website that was endorsed by the American Kennel Club. I see many similar recipes online, also with an almost 30% ratio of beeswax. This is so HARD (obviously) that it is extremely difficult to work with. Tried refrigerated cool down, room temp cool down and even whipping but it still is too firm.
I just cannot believe this is a good recipe and pictures I have seen with articles show a softer result.
I converted the recipe to percentages and added in a bit of Vitamin E. The only thing I can think is that I used solid coconut oil instead of fractionated (recipe did not specify fractionated) but I would not imagine that to make a great difference.

28.1% Refined Shea Butter
28.6% Coconut Oil
28.6% White Beeswax
14.2% Olive Oil
.5% Vitamin E

How can a recipe this stiff (rock hard almost) be popular?

Is there something I am missing?

Does someone here have a better recipe?

Any suggestions appreciated.

Thank you.

 

[bookworm42]

This looks very similar to a lotion bar recipe which is normally 1/3 of beeswax, hard oil (Shea), and soft oil(coconut/olive). They tend to be hard especially in the winter but do great once you rub it on skin and they start melting. Lots more info about them on this forum if you search for it.
The Shea and beeswax are the big contributers to the hardness. I would decrease one or both of them and increase the coconut oil or olive oil.

If you want something really soft you could look into doing a whipped body butter with the same ingredients minus the beeswax.

 

[AliOop]

The only thing I can think is that I used solid coconut oil instead of fractionated (recipe did not specify fractionated) but I would not imagine that to make a great difference.

Actually, using FCO instead of regular CO will make a huge difference to the final texture and hardness. You might want to give that a try.

 

[BigDog]

I ended up reformulating using Shea butter, mango butter, Jojoba Oil, Argan Oil, Sweet Almond Oil, Apricot Kernel Oil, Vitamin E and reduced BEESWAX to 15%. These are products I have on hand always so giving it a go.
It is a very workable, stiff consistency and I feel I can likely up the beeswax to 20% and still be good.
I’ll have to test this out for a while. If anyone would like to critique my new formulation I’ll post it.

 

[MGM]

Hi @BigDog ! I was just thinking of making something for my pupper. I was going to just use one of my regular body bar recipes, but I have all of those oils (because of course I do....) so if you want to share your recipe, I'll make it and let you know what she thinks of it.

 

[MGM]

BTW, she doesn't look sad because she's locked out. She's sad because no one will throw the ball 24/7, which is what she wants. That and food.

 

[Shirley-D]

(Oh I know that look!)
Wont the dog just lick it off?

 

[BigDog]

Yes, my girls will lick at it but it soaks in quickly and does the job before they can do much. That’s normal and harmless behavior.

Both girls LOVE IT and will stick their paws out willingly for the massage. I coat the outside of their toes, in between the toes, the pads and in-between, dew claw and if course their noses.

I do their noses first and then put a smear across their lips. They enjoy licking that while I do their feet. Once a day in the morning. Cookies to follow as a reward.

This is a new recipe, but I have been doing this routine for about 6 months. Noses and paws soft and supple and one of our girls has some food allergy issues and this seems to help with her feet itching. She will still chew occasionally but seems to be doing much much better now. I AM NOT MAKING ANY CLAIMS OF MEDICINAL QUALITIES, just my opinion and observation. There is research of beeswax and other oils having some healing properties but do your own research.

I made this recipe using oils and butters from responsibly sourced suppliers and some of my criteria was because it’s what I have on hand. You can make this much cheaper with coconut oils and such but that was not my goal.

Let me get back to you on my formulation, have to look it up.