Disappointed with my soaps. :cry:

Soapmaking Forum

Help Support Soapmaking Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
What sort of scale do you use? When I started soaping, we blamed certain VERY drying soaps on the recipe, or on an herb we added. I only later learned that because we were using a cheap spring-type kitchen scale, and making small batches, we likely had very low or even no superfat sometimes, because the scale was so inaccurate. One or more of our soaping books showed that type of scale, so we thought we'd be fine. We would decide our measurement was OK if 2 out of 3, or 3 out of 5 times we measured it, it weighed what we wanted. (Those other times the weight would be plenty different).

So, if that's the sort of scale you're using, please, please get a digital scale! they're from $20-$30, and you can promise yourself you'll use it to portion out food, too, or whatever you need to justify getting accurate measurements for soaping! :)
 
Digital Scale

Best advice when I first started making soap was a digital scale. Mine cost about $30. I have always followed each recipe exactly to the letter (or OZ) and have been very happy. I now have favorites. Everyone must have a recalculating (zero out) digital scale. No exceptions! Just sayn' ... :D
 
just my opinion from my own personal likes (I have very dry skin)
but looks like your olive oil is too low, your using too much palm oil and too much castor oil and your coconut oil is too low for the amount of olive oil. also a really good oil for dry skin is avocado. My research shows me that kukui nut oil is really good for eczema as well as some tamanu oil, these are expensive oils but you only need maybe a 1/2 oz of ea per 1 lb batch of soap. I also like my INS number to be around 160. Again this is just what works for me.

Dei
 
As the others said, don't give up! What I though of is do you hard or soft water? Hard water can be very drying to the skin. Just a thought. I agree with the others, keep the oils more simple like. My fave combo is CO, OO, PO and castor ( 5-7.5%). I use an 8% sf.
 
Found Non-Drying Soap! Yay!

Hopefully people won't mind me resurrecting this thread, but everyone has been so very kind with their suggestions and advices. So I wanted to report back. A very lovely and sweet member here sent me two bars of 90% OO soaps, one of which has been curing for over a year! Lucky me, huh? Anyway, I've been using it for a few days now, and guess what, it's not drying out my skin! Yay! Not only that, it's bubbles galore. I am not exaggerating one bit. This thing bubbles like crazy. :D I'm in love. It's 90% OO and 10% castor. I'll have to ask her whether there were any other additives. I am so happy. Oh, and I have double checked my digital scale with five quarters, and it is accurate. I guess I'll have to make tons of Castile type soaps to store away for future use.
 
Re: Found Non-Drying Soap! Yay!

Francis said:
A very lovely and sweet member here sent me two bars of 90% OO soaps, one of which has been curing for over a year! Lucky me, huh?

Aww, this place rocks!
 
Re: Found Non-Drying Soap! Yay!

saltydog said:
Francis said:
A very lovely and sweet member here sent me two bars of 90% OO soaps, one of which has been curing for over a year! Lucky me, huh?

Aww, this place rocks!

That was VERY nice!
 
Wonderful thread!!

I thoroughly have enjoyed reading this and most all of the other threads. As a mega-newbie to soap making (I have made 1 batch from a kit...)I love learning all I can. Tomorrow I am going to try my 1st castille soap... so reading this thread helps me figure out what I need to do. Sounds like the KISS method... Did I mention that I am so glad to have found this Forum? WOhoo! :D
 

Latest posts

Back
Top