I have spent a lot of time, effort and a small fortune in search for a true coconut fragrance for CP soap. I'm extremely picky about fragrances. Any fruit or floral fragrance has to be dead-on without any morphing or under notes. You name the vendor and I've tried their coconut. If they didn't have fruity under notes or faded into nothing, the finished soap smelled like vomit or morphed into a weird petrochemical smell when used.
Early on in my quest for the perfect coconut, I briefly used Camden Grey. It was the best of the worst coconuts. The scent was light, and produced a petrochemical undernote that dissipated after 8 months. Who can wait 8 months to sell a batch? So, I stopped making it and gave up.
I stumbled upon Just Scent's Coconut Extreme while looking for another fragrance. I was reluctant to try it as I had no success with their other coconuts, but I figured what the heck, what's one more ... and I'm glad I did.
OOB, Coconut Extreme has a heady, rich coconut scent. You may detect a whiff of vanilla and a peach note, but the predominant scent is pure, fresh coconut. It doesn't smell like suntan oil, extract or coconut pie.
At 1 oz ppo at normal temps, the fragrance does not accelerate in CP soap. It discolors to a milk chocolate brown, about the color of a coconut shell, which I don't mind. I add coconut powder to give it texture.
Here's how Coconut Extreme is different from any other coconut I've tried:
- Sticks when unmolded. Other coconuts are seem to disappear and then bounce back after curing for a few weeks.
- Pure coconut scent, not coconut and something else. Other coconuts include other, unidentified scents that resemble Hawaiian Tropic suntan oil or a pina colada.
- You smell the coconut when using it, not coconut and plastic. So many coconut and vanilla fragrances include a compound that to my nose smells like vomit when running under warm water. This one does not. You only smell the coconut.
I cannot say for certain how long the scent holds or if it morphs over longer periods. I don't have any bars that are more than 6 months old, but all indicators point to this being a sticker that won't morph.
Hope this was helpful ... I've been reading this forum for years but never posted until I saw this tread and sympathized with the coconut conundrum.