WSP's fresh cut rose

[Ruthie]

Is this a good FO? It is on sale this month. I've been using Lebermuth's Rose Petals for years which I adore. I am getting together a WSP order and wondered if I would be disappointed as I am pretty spoiled.

P.S. I know NG has a good Rose FO but am making an order to WSP.....

 

[cmzaha]

Sorry, I cannot help you there as I really do not like any WSP FO's other than their Frank & Myrr. I can say that Soapalooza has a fantastic rose that has just a hint of woody note. I have my 2 rose fo soaps next to each other and the Soapalooza sells 2:1. I you have a good one that sells well, if you are selling, I would not change.

 

[pamielynn]

Seize. Seize. Seize. Seize. It seizes on me every.frickin'.time. Theirs AND Nature's Garden's Fresh Cut Roses.

 

[Ellacho]

I love Elements Bath & Body's Sensuous Black Rose FO. No seizing in CP.

 

[hlee]

I just used NG fresh cut roses and it behaved well for me.
I liked it out of the bottle. I mixed it with amber and it's really nice.

 

[Skatergirl46]

Do any of these truly smell like a rose, with no other notes? I do a lot of HP so it doesn't matter if they accelerate to me.

 

[Paintguru]

I've used NG's Fresh Cut Roses, and to me (I'm a guy though) it smells just like a rose with no other notes. Behaved perfectly for me, but I used it in a salt bar.

 

[Numbers]

I use NG fresh cut roses also and never had any problems soaping with it. Out of the bottle it smells as close to the real thing as you can get but I always pair it with other scents when I use it so I don't know how it smells on its own once it's cured.

 

[OliveOil2]

I love the smell of this FO, but have only used it is melt & pour roses. I remember many of the WSP reviews mentioned seizure. I'm wondering how the NG hold up in curing?

 

[Paintguru]

I'm wondering how the NG hold up in curing?

So far so good after ~5 weeks.

 

[kaliquen]

I just soaped with their victorian rose and it was nice, I don't recall any acceleration (I soap room temp), but it is STRONG! I'd recommend using less than half your normal fragrance amount with this one.