I save my extra virgin organic for non soaped items, and especially coconut flavored since the natural smell definitely comes through on lip balm, etc.
I also EAT that kind as well (3 TBS a day is magical) - I also prefer the 76 degree CO.
the lye monster eats the good smell but virgin is ohh soo good fro your skin and body the coconut is a complete food use the oil in place of lotion. i literally bathe int he stuff