I always thought I had to get to emulsion before splitting my batch for coloring. However, I saw a good YT soaper (can't remember who) say that it's ok to split your batch before your emulsion is stable. The idea was that it is evenly mixed at that point, and the mixing that you do with the colorants will bring it to stable emulsion. I tried that this time, and it worked! My colorants were charcoal and TD, both of which thicken the batter quickly, so I figured this was the batch to try it. If you get to do another challenge batch, I'd encourage you to try it, too!
Planed and beveled my non-entry SMF August Challenge soaps. Same recipe, same colorants, just different molds. Can you guess which one gelled?
I'll give you a hint: the ones on the right are way more muted than they look in the pic. No pop, just muted muddiness.
View attachment 48865