That recipe always has the partial gel look, no matter if it's ungelled or if I know for a fact that it fully gelled, and it goes away not too long after being cut. It stays soft for a loooong time, too, the bars are still really fragile and smooshable and will be for a few days still. Once it's had a nice long cure, though.....mmm.
The basic recipe is 60% OO, 25ish% CO and/or PKO, 7% castor, and the rest either shea or cocoa butter or something more exotic like avocado butter or oil, I make minor little changes from batch to batch but that's the gist of it.
That particular batch is 60% OO, 12% CO, 12% PKO, 9% shea, and 7% castor, sf at 9%, also has tussah silk and honey. SoapCalc numbers are Hardness 31 (but it gets rock hard after the long cure), Cleansing 15, Conditioning 65, Bubble and Creamy both at 22, Iodine 64, INS 135.