grumble mutter grumble So I'm wondering what the heck is up with my soap?? It's been over 24 hours, and the last time I made this particular recipe the soap was almost too hard to cut that long after pouring!
The loaf, still mostly in the liner, is nice and hard on top, but the bottom is still pretty squishy, especially along the long edges. I also saw a couple of drops of clear liquid that had seeped out from where the liner overlaps. Didn't test it to see if it was oil or lye, figure whichever it is any that's left on the actual soap will reabsorb. I'll zap test when I actually cut it.
I've got both ends of the loaf uncovered, and I can't see any apparent separation or spots that look yellowish or crumbly or other issues. I'm pretty much certain that I did not have false trace, since it was over an hour from the time I mixed my oils and lye to the time I got the batter in the mold and during that time it maintained a temp of about 100 F and kept a homogeneous appearance. I've also double checked my measurements and made sure I didn't leave anything out or put too much of anything in.
For now, I'll let it sit with as much of the liner removed as I could get off without damaging the loaf. Hopefully it will finish hardening up in another day or two. If not, I'll stick it in the fridge or freezer for a bit just so I can at least get the liner off it.
Edit:
I think I've managed to answer most of my own questions here. I made a small change to the proportions in the recipe between the two batches- first had 40% OO and 15% RBO; second had 30% OO and 25% RBO, and increased the water content- 40% lye concentration in the first batch, 33% for the second. I also mixed at a higher temperature for the first batch than I did for this one. I think those three things pretty well account for this soap taking longer to harden up. The seepage, I don't know, but it seems to have all reabsorbed and/or evaporated at this point so unless my soap never finishes setting up or is zappy once it does I won't worry about it.
I made the changes to the lye concentration and temperature mostly with the expectation of my EO blend (half ylang) causing the soap to accelerate. That acceleration never happened.