Amal Sudhakaran
New Member
- Joined
- Jul 11, 2024
- Messages
- 2
- Reaction score
- 0
review this recipe please
- Thread starter Amal Sudhakaran
- Start date
Help Support Soapmaking Forum:
Thanks for posting the entire recipe - that is very helpful for giving feedback. Also, good job on starting with a nice small batch of only 1000g. You could even go down to 500g for testing; that makes 4-5 bars.
Here are my thoughts about everything else:
1. Change your lye setting from water as percent of oils to lye concentration. That will make it easier to adjust water higher or lower as needed, and to keep a consistent viscosity between batches of different sizes. Setting the lye concentration at 33% is a good starting place for beginners.
2. Reduce your superfat to 5% to lower the amount of soap scum and potential for rancidity.
3. Soap made with this much palm oil is going to feel like a piece of plastic your hand. With that much coconut oil, it's also very high on the cleansing value, which could make the skin feel tight and dry (and might be why you set the superfat so high). Honestly, I don't think people would like this much.
Can you add any kind of liquid oil, or do you have access to any butters or animal fats? Here is a suggestion:
40% liquid oil (olive, sunflower, avocado, sweet almond safflower, rice bran, sunflower)
35% palm oil (you could also use lard or tallow)
20% coconut oil (you could also use babassu, or palm kernel oil - not the same as palm oil)
33% lye concentration, 5% SF. Dissolve 1 T of plain white sugar in your distilled water before you add the NaOH. This will help the soap to lather more easily (but will not show that in the soap calculator).
Here are my thoughts about everything else:
1. Change your lye setting from water as percent of oils to lye concentration. That will make it easier to adjust water higher or lower as needed, and to keep a consistent viscosity between batches of different sizes. Setting the lye concentration at 33% is a good starting place for beginners.
2. Reduce your superfat to 5% to lower the amount of soap scum and potential for rancidity.
3. Soap made with this much palm oil is going to feel like a piece of plastic your hand. With that much coconut oil, it's also very high on the cleansing value, which could make the skin feel tight and dry (and might be why you set the superfat so high). Honestly, I don't think people would like this much.
Can you add any kind of liquid oil, or do you have access to any butters or animal fats? Here is a suggestion:
40% liquid oil (olive, sunflower, avocado, sweet almond safflower, rice bran, sunflower)
35% palm oil (you could also use lard or tallow)
20% coconut oil (you could also use babassu, or palm kernel oil - not the same as palm oil)
33% lye concentration, 5% SF. Dissolve 1 T of plain white sugar in your distilled water before you add the NaOH. This will help the soap to lather more easily (but will not show that in the soap calculator).
artemis
Mostly Harmless
- Joined
- Feb 27, 2016
- Messages
- 2,635
- Reaction score
- 4,517
Haha, good catch!
artemis
Mostly Harmless
- Joined
- Feb 27, 2016
- Messages
- 2,635
- Reaction score
- 4,517
I redid the math about 5 times before I was sure there was a mistake...
Me + Math = Many Mistakes
They are the same thing, expressed two different ways. While lye concentration seems to be used more frequently, you should use the one that makes the most sense to you.
Elly’s Everyday Soapmaking on YouTube has a good video which explains the differences in how lye is expressed in Soapcalc.
Hey, I know it's a month old thread, but I noticed something and felt like sharing my angle.
You say 40% liquid oils (and mention it could be sunflower and safflower as well). I'm pretty sure that if you make soap with that high % sunflower or safflower it will give you DOS. Now, if they are of the high oleic variety, that's a different story...
DOS isn't automatic for any soap recipe, especially if one uses fresh oils, a chelator, and an antioxidant such as ROE.
Still, I do agree that to reduce the likelihood of DOS, it's best to try to keep the combined linoleic + linolenic number at 15 or less, either by using a blend of liquid oils, or by using high-oleic versions of sunflower, safflower, soybean, or canola oils (or doing both). That's good info for folks to know, so thank you for pointing it out.
Last edited:
No worries!DOS isn't automatic for any soap recipe, especially if one uses fresh oils, a chelator, and an antioxidant such as ROE.
Still, I do agree that to reduce the likelihood of DOS, it's best to try to keep the combined linoleic + linolenic number at 15 or less, either by using a blend of liquid oils, or by using high-oleic versions of sunflower, safflower, soybean, or canola oils (or doing both). That's good info for folks to know, so thank you for pointing it out.
I've had some batches with as little as 10% regular sunflower oil in them. All oils fresh, more than decent saturated fatty acid content, citric acid added in enough quantity, low SF and deionized water only. All of them developed DOS in 2 months and it got worse as time went by. And I never get DOS in the recipes with no sunflower oil - for that reason I just stopped using it altogether.
I agree that ROE may be good for recipes high in linoleic/linolenic, but it's not available everywhere, unfortunately. And even though you need a very small amount of it to be effective, it's still expensive.
For that reason, I would either keep the sunflower % minimal or omit it altogether as an ingredient - a beginner may get results not to their liking and that may lead to disappointment. Just my 2 cents
Yep, experiences definitely vary. Before knowing better, I’ve used up to 25% regular sunflower oil, and my soap never developed DOS. I do use a chelator in all my batches, and now I also add ROE to either my lard and tallow, or to my MB oil mixes.
