Pink Sugar Failure

[Nikon]

Ok, so I HP my soap, and I read so many reviews on Pink Sugar FO. The description of it sounded like something I would want to make, so I strolled into Sephora and smelled some Pink Sugar Lotion. It smelled just like the description. From what I could gather, many versions of Pink Sugar were great, but the scent works stood out with the best reviews from what I read. I decided to try BCN for it first because I was getting some other FO from them. OOB it smelled great, and I soaped it at .7 oz PPO. It had an extremely weak smell for a few days and it turned into a weird waxy smell. I decided to not give up and I gave the holy grail of Pink Sugar a try from the scent works. OOB it was great, and I soaped it at 0.7 oz PPO. It had a moderate aroma for a week or so and faded it almost nothing. If I put the soap right at my nose and sniff very hard, I can catch a slight wiff of a waxy Pink Sugar smell.....very disappointing considering the cost. Some time went by and I was placing an order from NG for a bunch of samples and I noticed the Pink Sugar. I figured what the hey, Ill order a sample. I decided to soap it at 1 oz PPO. It had a much stronger smell than the other two for a week, and now it has faded into nothing. Smells like unscented. Ive soaped enough to know how to add FO and I certainly didnt exceed the FP. Do I just have bad luck or what?

 

[Genny]

Hmmm..I never had any fading issues with NGC's & Scent Works' Pink Sugar I use it in CP at 5%, which is less than what you used. The scent stuck in both of them.
I've never HP'd that fo though.

 

[kharmon320]

That's odd... I've never HP'd Pink Sugar, but it worked fine in CP. It did fade eventually, but was plenty strong at 2 weeks. I've only used Peak's, haven't really tried any others because I hate the yellow/brown lather. Hope someone can help.