OK, I am going to tell you on the front end that I am incapable of sugar coating anything. I lack tact. Coming from a military and medical family, I just never learned it. I also had my sister-in-law look at the website as she has much more website, ebay, etc experience than I do. I think you came here for honest feedback. If you really don't want it, please stop reading here.
Overview-the home page needs to be the focus of the first thing I see. What I see now is that blurred image taking up more space than what I am there to see. Re-sizing the center would be better. Use more of the space. Proofread, proofread, proofread. Several typos are present throughout the site. The pictures on the home page don't take me anywhere. They should if they are taking up such prime real estate. Homemade might be better phrased handmade. Take the mental picture of the kitchen out of your product.
Home page- as mentioned above, products need to be there, and at the top. Break the thumbnails down by actual products. Not everything being listed when I click soaps. Move the About Us elsewhere.
About Us-I had my sister-in-law read it without me influencing her. She said(and I agree) that the first paragraph is great. The rest can go. We know that the lather is different. But the way that reads is that one will get no lather from your products because you did not add any of the lovely lather making ingredients. And the final line comes off as snarky. Both of us agree on that.
Product photos- The table is distracting. And the camera is too far away from the product. If I can't see it better, I am not going to trust that the item actually looks like that, and I am not going to buy it. Go check out some of the photos on Etsy of soaps and such. They are your competition.
Lotions-someone will need to verify if you are required to list everything in the base or not. I do not know. I DO know, however, that I would not buy anything with a first ingredient of lotion. I need to know what is in that product before buying. I would also hesitate to order that from a site that claims homemade with an incomplete label.
Lip balm-is not technically moisturizing. It should not have any water in it. If it does have anything besides oils, it needs preservative. Ditto with lotions. All ingredients should be listed.
Gift baskets-I like that you offered those. Makes you different. However, I would more likely order more than 1 item if you offered "bundles" of soap, lip balm, lotion or lotion bar in a box with lower shipping costs than that of a pre-made basket to me. You could conveniently locate the bundle for each scent on the soap page as well as the lotion page. Maybe offer a small discount for the bundle over buying the items individually. Run some dollar store tissue paper through a shredder and use that as festive box filler for gifts.(crumble the tissue paper first, straighten it out a bit, then shred)
Brick of soap-I just don't know of any nice ways to tell you how bad of an idea I think this is. First off, you don't tell them on the website when to cut it, how to cut it safely, or when it will be safe and good for use. I see a lawsuit in your near future. Someone is going to slice open something, or cut it completely off cutting that soap. Then they are going to take it straight to the shower or give it away that day to relatives, regardless of how large the font is on the warning page to wait 6 weeks before using. Never, never, never underestimate human stupidity. Everything must be idiot proof.