I swear I do not know for sure,, but if I recall throughout my readings, the FDA does not allow you to call it argan soap, shea butter soap, cocoa butter soap etc, UNLESS it's (argan oil, shea butter etc) the only ingredient in your soap. Someone else has to come up with the rules on this to confirm, but I am pretty sure this is what I've read in the past. I can't be positive though so take it with a grain of salt. May be what Carilyn was trying to state...