I've only tried three scents from there so far but they were all good.
Lime Margarita - Wow smells exactly like one, yum!
OMH - It's good but to me Brambleberries smells just as good and it's cheaper.
Hermes Eau des Merveilles - I don't soap this (too expensive) but in lotions it is very nice. I personally didn't see what the big deal was with it, but a couple friends that have smelled it thought it was the bee's knees.
I've used three of their's and love them ... Cool Water Christmas Spice - turns the soap a yummie caramel colour and did speed up a bit, but I had time to do a swirl and add some bits and pieces Sandalwood Vanilla