I haven't tried Salty Sailor - is it the one from Daystar? If so, I looked at the description online and they might be similar. SSDW has the ozone salty ocean smell, and then a woodsy undertone - it's not strong and women seem to like it as much as men. The one from daystar sounds like it might be a bit more floral. I'm looking for a replacement for SSDW because it has gotten so expensive (when I first started buying it was 22-something a pound and now it's up to 35-something). I just got one from NG - I can't remember the name and I'm too lazy to walk down to the soap dungeon to look, but I think it might be ocean mist? - that is close in scent (not as woodsy, a little floral) but I haven't soaped it yet. I'll definitely keep your acceleration warning in my head just in case!