Help me make my first lotion

Soapmaking Forum

Help Support Soapmaking Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
If you want to start with something simpler and less expensive, this one from Marie is great, too; I use jojoba oil instead of fractionated coconut oil since that's what my skin prefers. ETA: Meadowfoam seed oil would be another great choice. Pricey but oh so nice!

Good luck, have fun, and let us know how it turns out!
If “someone” decided to try this, could you add a FO? If so, what amount would that “someone” try? 😉
 
Question: How much aloe gel (I make and freeze my own in cubes) would I use in place of aloe juice? I see many recipes that use aloe juice in the water phase, but I'm not sure what the ratio of distilled water to aloe gel would be.
 
Question: How much aloe gel (I make and freeze my own in cubes) would I use in place of aloe juice? I see many recipes that use aloe juice in the water phase, but I'm not sure what the ratio of distilled water to aloe gel would be.
Personally, I wouldn't use aloe gel in my lotions; it's too difficult to preserve. The aloe juice I use is a distilled aloe juice.
 
Personally, I wouldn't use aloe gel in my lotions; it's too difficult to preserve. The aloe juice I use is a distilled aloe juice.
Wow, I didn't even know this existed! The one I just looked up (Swanson's) says it's fractionated and distilled. Does it have the same skin benefits? Every aloe liquid I knew of until now had preservatives and citric acid in it which is why I started making my own gel for soapmaking.
 
Wow, I didn't even know this existed! The one I just looked up (Swanson's) says it's fractionated and distilled. Does it have the same skin benefits? Every aloe liquid I knew of until now had preservatives and citric acid in it which is why I started making my own gel for soapmaking.
Soapmaking is different. The lye monster ensures that there's no "bug food" remaining. I use "George's", which is also fractionally distilled. I'm not sure about the properties; I have a feeling most things in creams and lotions (apart from the oil and water) are for label appeal more than anything.
 
If 3% hydrolyzed oat protein is in a recipe, would panthenol in the heated water phase work instead? I'd likely only use it at 2% and add 1% to....?
Panthenol, in creams and lotions, can be used up to 3% so, yes, you can sub it. If you're using hydrolyzed oat protein, I would use it in the cool down phase. If you want to use 2% of the panthenol, up the water by 1%.
 
Panthenol, in creams and lotions, can be used up to 3% so, yes, you can sub it. If you're using hydrolyzed oat protein, I would use it in the cool down phase. If you want to use 2% of the panthenol, up the water by 1%.
I thought that's how to do it, but wanted to confirm. Do you think this sub will still have similar end results? I haven't seen panthenol listed in any of the recipes I've been looking at, but I happen to have some on hand and I do not have any oat hydrolyzed protein.
 
I thought that's how to do it, but wanted to confirm. Do you think this sub will still have similar end results? I haven't seen panthenol listed in any of the recipes I've been looking at, but I happen to have some on hand and I do not have any oat hydrolyzed protein.
I've used it in lotions many times.
 
I know I am a little late to the party here, but can I make a suggestion? Oh well, I will anyway. Before adding in and playing with additives please make a simple lotion and learn the process. I spent over a year before I ever took a lotion to market or gave it away and this was after we had been selling and making lotions for a few years. My daughter had been making our lotions which we had lab tested, but I was unsure of the process.

This is a wonderful kit to start with and many here will know this is not my favorite supplier so I do not recommend her products lightly. Our first lotion was based on this kit many years ago, although she has tweaked the fragrance of the kit. It is a very easy recipe to tweak which we did and became our go-to lotion recipe and top-selling lotion. Her original kit and recipe included Phenonip I see she changed. Personally, I use a 2 preservative system, but that is my choice. The only way you can get this recipe is to buy the kit. Peaceful Lavender Lotion Kit | BrambleBerry

You can watch the video but cannot get the percentages of the ingredients and of course, the transcript does not show the recipe. I will add in my year of testing lotion formulas I had more failures than successes. Lotion does have a learning curve. But through it all, I came up with some really nice lotions.
 
@AliOop and @Misschief Ok, so shea and coconut don't play well together in lotion. Got it. What would you recommend to sub for coconut (other than sweet almond) if I keep the shea? I've read sunflower is a good candidate but I can't tell if that's regular or high oleic sunflower.
I don't think it matters as much in lotion as it does in soap. Another nice sub for coconut oil is babassu, if you have it. I would recommend trying a small batch of lotion with shea and coconut; I've never had lotions with both butters go grainy.
 
I don't think it matters as much in lotion as it does in soap. Another nice sub for coconut oil is babassu, if you have it. I would recommend trying a small batch of lotion with shea and coconut; I've never had lotions with both butters go grainy.
I actually gave away my babassu to a friend to try in her soap because I just wasn't using it. Lol.
I guess I could try coconut and shea in a small batch and see. We're talking about regular coconut oil, right? Not fractionated?
 
Back
Top