Hi everyone! I’m wondering if anyone ever found someplace that carries a dupe of SW’s Tonic? I have one 16 oz bottle left that still smells amazing and is performing well in CP, but I don’t want to be without it when it’s gone! 
Dupe SW's Tonic
- Thread starter Marie_with_an_e
- Start date
Help Support Soapmaking Forum:
SW?
- Joined
- Jun 2, 2017
- Messages
- 418
- Reaction score
- 666
Do you remember whether SW Tonic was a dupe of a perfume? Micas and More have a "The Tonic" that is a dupe of the perfume Hedonic Tonic. I have been thinking about ordering it to test.
I still have a small amount of a dupe of the SW one that I am still using in lotion bars. I don't have enough left for soap, but I agree The Scent Works one was very nice.
I still have a small amount of a dupe of the SW one that I am still using in lotion bars. I don't have enough left for soap, but I agree The Scent Works one was very nice.
Maple_Street_Bath
Well-Known Member
I'm late to this party... but I've used M&M Tonic FO... I don't recommend it - or at minimum if you plan to sell do a test batch and keep for at least 6 months before you make a batch to sell. I made soap with this FO twice, two different recipes, and both had DOS within a few months. Both of my recipes are good and I have soap bars that are 5+ years old, so it's not a recipe issue. I used it in some b&b products, and the fragrance went rancid. I have had issues with almost all of the FO's that I buy from M&M, so I only buy colors there now. Shame, because it is a lovely fragrance.
