Yep, I wasn't as happy with the zinc oxide either. Going to stick with the TD.I have used Zinc Oxide instead of TD a lot. But I have learned it yellows quite a bit faster so I would recommend it only if you are going to be selling them fairly soon so they don't yellow on your customers. It works at close to the same ratio and imo is close, but not quite as white. I used it a good bit when making soaps like pumpkin spice that have an orangey/yellow tint anyway so it works.