Comments Requested About FO from NDA
- Thread starter gsc
- Start date
Help Support Soapmaking Forum:
I have a few scents from NG and they seem to be a good quality and stick fine for me. I've liked all the ones I've ordered except bay rum.
Second Impression
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jan 8, 2013
- Messages
- 152
- Reaction score
- 132
Ones I've tried:
Green Apple - no acceleration, stays strong, discolors to PURPLE
Frankincense & Myrrh - didn't hold up at all in CP, completely gone by the time I unmolded.
Maple Pecan - smells nice, holds well, no acceleration but will discolor to brown
Bitter Almond - super strong and sticks around forever, no discoloration but be ready for acceleration and overheating.
Cranberry Peach Vanilla - behaves well in CP but doesn't come through strong at all, no discoloration.
All in all, I like NDA's FOs for non-CP applications. But I'll pay more for better preforming FO's from WSP.
Green Apple - no acceleration, stays strong, discolors to PURPLE
Frankincense & Myrrh - didn't hold up at all in CP, completely gone by the time I unmolded.
Maple Pecan - smells nice, holds well, no acceleration but will discolor to brown
Bitter Almond - super strong and sticks around forever, no discoloration but be ready for acceleration and overheating.
Cranberry Peach Vanilla - behaves well in CP but doesn't come through strong at all, no discoloration.
All in all, I like NDA's FOs for non-CP applications. But I'll pay more for better preforming FO's from WSP.
- Joined
- Oct 7, 2014
- Messages
- 241
- Reaction score
- 179
I like leaves from NDA but, it's not phlalate free which bothers me because it does smell awesome. And strong. No acceleration or discolouring.
Vanilla cream is nice, but I find a little bit more than 1tbs PPo is best for the smell to really pop. Accelerates a little and discolours to a dark brown I'll see if I can find my before and after pictures
Dragons blood is also nice and sticks but totally discolours to dark brown. Which of course I wasn't going for with red and black swirls. Accelerates a little.
I bought buttercream but haven't used it yet, as well as Japanese cherry blossom for my mother in law because she's a BBw snob.
Pumpkin patch (I think is the phlalate free one) and it smells really nice, fAdes to brown.
Coffee spice cake smells just like pumpkin patch to me in the soap. Oob is different.
Vanilla cream is nice, but I find a little bit more than 1tbs PPo is best for the smell to really pop. Accelerates a little and discolours to a dark brown I'll see if I can find my before and after pictures
Dragons blood is also nice and sticks but totally discolours to dark brown. Which of course I wasn't going for with red and black swirls. Accelerates a little.
I bought buttercream but haven't used it yet, as well as Japanese cherry blossom for my mother in law because she's a BBw snob.
Pumpkin patch (I think is the phlalate free one) and it smells really nice, fAdes to brown.
Coffee spice cake smells just like pumpkin patch to me in the soap. Oob is different.
