This is like asking me to pick a favorite child. I love love love smell goodies. Okay, right now, and this changes daily, I'd say I'm loving:
Pink Watermelon from Nature's Garden. It was the FO of the month a month or so back and I'm so glad I went for a big bottle. It is strong and true, leaves some of the smell on your skin after using it and my girls adore it.
Cool Water Type from NG. Hubby loves it.
Magnolia Melba from Southern Garden Scents. I only had a sniffy sample, so just one bar and I'm hording it so I can sniff. Guess I'm gonna have to get some more. The truth is that I haven't met many FOs from SGS that I don't like. Black Vetiver Cafe, High Voltage, Lemon Sugar....I could go on and on.
Grapefruit Lily from DayStar. OMG! I almost forgot about this one, but I really love it. Made a 2 lb batch and have only shared three bars. I'm being greedy with this one. I also only had 2 oz of the FO so I'll need to reorder soon.