Stephenson Foaming Bath Butter vs. Crafter's Choice Foaming Bath Whip

[homesteaders]

Have any of you used both -- the Stephenson Foaming Bath Butter, and the Crafter's Choice Foaming Bath Whip? Even if you've only used one, can you tell me what you like or don't like about them? Do they both double in volume once they are properly whipped?

I read a review saying the Stephenson's was crumbly after whipping, but that review was written a year or so ago. Of course, I don't know how long the product has been on the shelf before being shipped and then whipped into a product to sell. I am considering buying it from Jedwards because it is so much cheaper than the Crafter's Choice from WSP, but if it's crumbly, it will be worthless. Thanks for any info.

 

[homesteaders]

Also, is there much difference between using a hand mixer and a stand mixer? How many 8oz. jars of bath whip can be expected after fully whipping? Thanks!