What a great Fragrance from New Directions Aromatics. I just tested it in a 1lb batch and will update as to its holding power. It soaped fantastic with no acceleration using a 33% lye concentration. Not sure about discoloration so will try to remember to update. I used tallow, shea, palm, rbo and castor with no coconut or pko, just let the tallow add a low cleansing number. This fragrance reminds me of a mix of chutney and mulled wine. Will be ordering another 2lbs next week. I love NDA