I've got a buyer who buys soap from me once per year for 3 years. She only wants the same scent, same colors. I was going for an Ione swirl and do wish this was more Ione-y and swirlier but it is what it is. I poured at the thinnest emulsion ever and I was worried about the colors muddling together so I didn't do a lot of swirls with the gear tie. Smells great, orange, lavender, anise, cedarwood.