I've only bought 2 so far, BB Berrywine and CS Chardonnay. The berrywine smells more like berry than wine to me, but I slap a label on it calling it wine soap (I did use old vine zin as half the water) and everyone I've given it to has gone crazy over it. I haven't soaped the chardonnay yet, but it smells very wine-y in the bottle.