I have yet to find a honetsuckle I adore. I also can not find a peach or a coconut I can live with. Some scents are just harder to match than others I guess.
I impulsively bought 1 oz of Honeysuckle from Glory Bee Foods here in Eugene, OR. http://www.glorybeefoods.com I don't know what honeysuckle smells like, but my mother says it's pretty close.
I am in love with the Heavenly Honeysuckle from AromaHaven. (there are two, this one is the best). Very strong, very true and not too hard to work with (considering it is a floral.)
I had a customer who was dying for the "right" honeysuckle so I bought all I could find LOL and tried them all. She chose Honeysuckle Vine from Mill Creek, saying it was perfect.
My favorite of what I tried though was "Morning Glory & Honeysuckle" from NG.
The Honeysuckle Hollow smells very nice. I put some on the hand and then washed it off and the smell is lingering. Pretty close to the real thing I think.
I don't know if I'm going to soap with it, although I suppose I should. I only bought the sample bottle. I might just make a tiny batch to see.
I just bought some Honeysuckle Hollow too, I really like it! I've been looking for something that smells like Pottery Barn's Honeysuckle candles/diffusers and I think I found it!