I can't really remember the scent of the old time Pear's. The original scent ingredients were thyme, rosemary and Pear's essence FO. I didn't have thyme so improvised. My version is in the tutorial section. For a beginner, melting the pine rosin might be a challenge. I tried to melt the stearic acid and pine rosin in a double boiler, but that didn't work. I finally added the Castor oil to the rosin/stearic acid and melted in the microwave. That seems to work best.