Liquid soap dilution failed

Soapmaking Forum

Help Support Soapmaking Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

BillOB

Member
Joined
Dec 27, 2018
Messages
14
Reaction score
8
Location
Canada
Have I failed my dilution process?I have let the bottle settle for overnight already and the soap layered into to two.The top creamy bubbly layer and the bottom translusent layer. I have tried to stir it more to make them mix together but they will layer again once settled down for a while.I'm guessing i have not diluted enough. My recipe is as following:
Olive oil 30%
Coconut oil 25%
Palm oil 20%
Caster oil 5%
Jojoba oil 5%
Wheat germ oil 5%
Sweet almond oil 5%
Shea oil 5%
Oil total in 500g
Potassium hydroxied 105g
Water 160g
Glycerin 160g

Dilution ratio :150g paste and 250g water.I actually started diluting with 4 to 3 paste and water ratio but that didnt dilute the paste completly so I increase the water amount to the above amount to get complete dilution.

Need some advice on this
Thanks!
 

Attachments

  • AAD0CC8D-056C-4E74-9B96-87EB6E00565B.jpeg
    AAD0CC8D-056C-4E74-9B96-87EB6E00565B.jpeg
    40.3 KB
  • 6C42E7B2-F366-4B9C-B436-6423FE96510D.jpeg
    6C42E7B2-F366-4B9C-B436-6423FE96510D.jpeg
    38.2 KB
Last edited:
I don't think it's your dilution I think it may be your recipe. Jojoba is a wax and has a lot of unsaponifiables. Plus you have whatever SF you entered for your recipe. So you have a higher SF and the fats may be separating out. However, I'm not a pro by any measure on LS so hopefully someone with more experience than I will pipe in with their thoughts.
 
Nope, the problem has nothing to do with dilution.

I haven't run your recipe through my calculator, so I don't know the superfat. Too much superfat could be an issue. If your KOH has a low purity, this could be contributing to a too-high superfat if you have not compensated for the KOH purity.

Another is you're using jojoba that contains a high % of unsaponifiables, as Shari noted, and you are also using fats high in stearic and palmitic acids. Both issues will make a cloudy liquid soap that may separate, especially the high stearic-palmitic content.
 
Nope, the problem has nothing to do with dilution.

I haven't run your recipe through my calculator, so I don't know the superfat. Too much superfat could be an issue. If your KOH has a low purity, this could be contributing to a too-high superfat if you have not compensated for the KOH purity.

Another is you're using jojoba that contains a high % of unsaponifiables, as Shari noted, and you are also using fats high in stearic and palmitic acids. Both issues will make a cloudy liquid soap that may separate, especially the high stearic-palmitic content.
my super fat is 2%
I’ll try no palm oil next time and see how it goes.
 
Back
Top