I <3 the Color, but will they???

Soapmaking Forum

Help Support Soapmaking Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

AngelMomma

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 28, 2012
Messages
1,032
Reaction score
682
Location
Central Louisiana
I know a couple of people with little ones with delicate skin that is eczema prone. My sister being the main one that I am concerned with providing a gentle simple soap. I make a beautiful soap for my daughters eczema prone skin, but I adjusted the recipe to simplify that even more. So I came up with a BEAUTIFUL batch of Buttermilk Baby soap. Olive oil, Lard, Coconut Oil, and Castor with plenty of SF. Part of the liquid was the Buttermilk added to the oils and SB and also a couple of tsp. of sugar melted in 1oz of water added almost at trace. I KNEW that the sugars would darken, or change the color somewhat if it went through gel. I always have prefered gelling. But I am wondering now if people are bothered by the color of a soap if it seems there is no coloring in it. I don't sell my soaps. But if I send my sis some it is labeled as close to 'RIGHT' as possible. Now I'm thinking, what if someone sent me a soap that the Ingredients read...........Olive oil, Lard, Coconut Oil, Castor Oil, Distillied Water, Buttermilk and Sugar. BUT the soap is a lovely PEACH color!!! It really is a pretty color. Are people usually bothered by that? Maybe I could put something on the label that would indicate where the color came from??? I was going to send her a couple of bars so she could have one and give one to her friend that has a little one with the same problems. I wouldn't want anyone to think that I omitting ingredients :confused:. If ppl tend to be turn off by this color issue I might just HAVE to freeze it the next time I make a batch.


If I had some kind of Peachy Fragrance it would go perfectly with this recipe! :)

Buttermilk Baby.jpg
 
It actually looks slightly more 'peachy' than the picture shows. The pic is from a few days ago when I unmolded and it doesn't seem to have changed. I wonder if it will turn more tan in the weeks to come...........
 
A lot of folks love all-natural soaps. If they have sensitive skin, especially. I am sure they will love it!
 
It is lovely and natural. Most people don't realize most white soaps like ivory are full of chemicals to get to that color.
 
If they have sensitive skin, definitely skip the fragrances. The soap is lovely!
 
The color is beautiful and I don't think people will be concerned about it. The peachy color makes it look even more gentle than if it had been white. If anyone asks, just tell them it's from the sugar being heated by saponification. I also think some of the color is from the buttermilk. Milk can turn an orangy color when combined with lye.
 
Thank you all for your comments! Guess I will trust that they will like it as much as I do :lol: I think have a bit of a complex now. Seems people either think I am SO WEIRD(for making soap):shock: or they absolutely love the idea. I just never know what it will be. Thanks again!
 
That is very pretty! I have not had people ask about my unscented/uncolored soaps when they have a natural color from the ingredients I use. More and more people I know seem to want that kind so I always have some on hand, it seems like I know more people now with skin issues than I used to.
 
Seems people either think I am SO WEIRD(for making soap):shock: or they absolutely love the idea. I just never know what it will be. Thanks again!

Honey, they KNOW I am weird, but they love my soaps. :) I agree with Kansas Farm Girl. "Natural" is a big factor in people loving handmade soaps. But it would not hurt to put "uncolored and unscented" on the label.
 
Some people make unscented, all-natural soap a selling point. On Etsy, there is a guy who sells it under the name Rocky Top Soap, and he seems to do well.
 
The peach in your soap will change to a lovely tan, it's just a ph thing right now. I think users of handmade soap will understand and like the fact that your soaps have a natural color and not a fake white from TD.
 
Back
Top