Help me decide?

[John Harris]

Gonna make some ITP soap... Which one should I do?

1. Cedarwood EO with White base with light brown and green accents.
2. Three Wise Men FO (Frankincense, Myrrh, etc.) Natural base (it discolors a bit) and Turmeric and Paprika accents.
3. Love Spell FO with a white base and dark pink accent.

Keep in mind that Christmas is coming! (OMG!!)

 

[maryloucb]

1. If you are going to do cedarwood EO, I would pair it with another EO (there are some good blends listed on eocalc.com.) I love the idea of the white with brown and green.
2. This sounds amazing
3. This sounds amazing as well, but maybe more suited to valentines day?

 

[Cat&Oak]

Okay I'll play your silly game #2 sounds amazing

 

[ResolvableOwl]

Which one should I do?

Yes.

 

[John Harris]

Yes.

Grrrrr.....

 

[Zing]

Um, all of the above. Your Christmas gifts can be variety packs!

 

[Arimara]

Um, all of the above. Your Christmas gifts can be variety packs!

I like this idea the most, if it's not too much trouble.

 

[John Harris]

Um, all of the above. Your Christmas gifts can be variety packs!

To my amazement, my family has never really cared for my soaping. The general public however has raved about it. I never understood it but learned to live with it.

 

[Zing]

To my amazement, my family has never really cared for my soaping. The general public however has raved about it. I never understood it but learned to live with it.

No one is a prophet in their own land.

 

[John Harris]

No one is a prophet in their own land.

Ain't it the truth....

 

[John Harris]

I like this idea the most, if it's not too much trouble.

I plan to make all three! It's just a matter of what I am going to make tonight.

 

[Bubble Agent]

If you are making 1 soap a day you could make #1 Cedarwood tonight, #3 Love spell tomorrow, and last #2 Three Wise men.
That way your olfactory system gets a rest between the two heavier ones, and the more sweet and lighter type can be the "cleanser" inbetween?

(I should really be in bed by now, but happened to pop in and saw this. Now I`m off...)

 

[John Harris]

If you are making 1 soap a day you could make #1 Cedarwood tonight, #3 Love spell tomorrow, and last #2 Three Wise men.
That way your olfactory system gets a rest between the two heavier ones, and the more sweet and lighter type can be the "cleanser" inbetween?

(I should really be in bed by now, but happened to pop in and saw this. Now I`m off...)

Thanks, Bubbles! Oh! I mean Bubble!

 

[Mobjack Bay]

To my amazement, my family has never really cared for my soaping. The general public however has raved about it. I never understood it but learned to live with it.

Do you want to be in my family? Then we can brag on each other .

 

[John Harris]

Do you want to be in my family? Then we can brag on each other .

SURE!!!

 

[John Harris]

DARN!! Tonight's soaping project has been scuttled!

Got all the soapmaking stuff out and was ready to commence with prepping the lye. Went to the freezer and found ... NO ICE! Do I go to the store or postpone till Friday?

Friday will be okay, I guess. It was going to be The Three Wiseman. I was so excited at trying my hand on another ITP.

(I soaped once with no ice. The surface of the hot lye liquid melted a line around my plastic pitcher!)

 

[ResolvableOwl]

2. Three Wise Men FO (Frankincense, Myrrh, etc.) Natural base (it discolors a bit) and Turmeric and Paprika accents.

Don't forget the gold (sprinkling, mica lines, etc.) – in case you don't want to overstretch the budget, it doesn't have to be real gold.

 

[Vicki C]

Um, all of the above. Your Christmas gifts can be variety packs!

just sayin…

 

[KiwiMoose]

Three wisemen sounds great for Christmas!
Then love spell.
Cedarwood - I second @maryloucb 's suggestion that you pair it with something else - maybe a citrus?

 

[earlene]

View attachment 60885
just sayin…

Love that box. Who sells it?