Is there something that you want? Let's say a nice bottle of cabernet? If so, maybe you could find someone's failed homemade batch...give a bottle. That way she may think you like wine and voila! You are set...LOL.
Seriously, I get it. I was at a wedding shower a few weeks ago and the "favors" were liquid soap from the dollar store. We stayed a little late since we are family and the guest of honor kept wanting to give me the EXTRAS...., I make soap, I don't need anymore. As a matter of fact, you could probably give my favor to old Aunt Mary who would be delighted to go home with an extra soap favor.
I like the idea of donating it to the shelters. Every year my friend gets donations together and makes Christmas bags for a short term domestic violence shelter. They would love to have ANYthing like this. In addition to anyone who is looking for a donation for some type of auction.