These are the main manly scents that the menfolk in my sphere of influence really like:
-Paradise (Daystar)- an effervescent lime scent
-Salty Sailor (Daystar)- a salty sea air fragrance
-Santa's Pipe (SweetCakes)- smells just like cherry tobacco
-Old Spice Classic- (Oregon Trails)- smells just like the real deal to my nose
-The Perfect Man (NaturesGarden)- smells like a very manly grapefruit
-Montego Bay (Oregon Trails)- smells exactly like the real Bay Racemosa EO to my nose
-Barbershop 1920's (Rustic Escentuals)- hubby says it smells just like his dad after a shave at the barbershop. It brought back a lot of memories for him.
-Twilight Woods (Peak's)- a pleasant woodsy scent with a slight vanilla undertone to my nose
-Soapy Clean (Brambleberry)- smells just like Tone soap.
-Sugared Spruce (WSP)- smells just like you'd imagine it would smell like. Very aptly named.
-Cedar & Saffron (Brambleberry)- doesn't smell like cedar or saffron to my nose, but it does smell quite lovely- it reminds me of the smells of Christmas.
There's more I could mention, I'm sure, but those are the biggies.
IrishLass