First batch - recipe check

Soapmaking Forum

Help Support Soapmaking Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Vidja

New Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2020
Messages
2
Reaction score
1
Location
Sweden
I will soon try cold process soap for the first time. I have read up on basics and scrolled through the forum, reading threads that looked like they would be able to teach me more. Mostly I just got confused though as there is contradicting info from different people, or sometimes the same person. But anyway.
I was going to keep it simple to start with as I don't want to spend a ton of money before I know if it is something I want to keep doing. Want to do it mainly because I wash my hands MANY times every day because of my job and my hands get very dry, even worse in winter.
I was planning on doing 70% Olive oil and 30% coconut oil. I came across a few posts mentioning people doing this and they like it. And others saying they find soaps high in olive oil to feel slimey, which gave me second thoughts.
I am tempted to add sheabutter to it, but can't decide if I should, or try that my second batch. People that use sheabutter in their soaps claim it's great, while I saw a couple of posts saying that they didn't notice a difference until 20% shea or more.
What would you suggest I do? 70% olive, 30% coconut or
55% Olive, 25% coconut 20% shea ?
I am also wondering if a 70 OO 30 CO would require longer than a month to cure with the high olive oil content?
And have I understood it correct that the default 38% water/liquid to oils that the soapcalculators have is what is recommended for beginners?
I see most people here use palmoil in their recipes, assuming a lot of americans. Palmoil is something I will never use,mainly for environmental reasons. But also because it is hardly sold at all in my country and it has the same higher price as butters. Mentioning this in case someone was going to suggest PO. :)
 

Attachments

  • sheaolivecoco.pdf
    50.2 KB
  • olivecoco.pdf
    50.1 KB
I'd run with the 55% Olive, 25% CO and 20% Shea. Most people tend to find any more than 25% CO too drying, and indeed, a lot of us tend to use less than that. If you can get castor oil it might be nice to use 20% CO with 5% castor instead. But give the recipe a go as-is if not and let us know what you think. You will be able to use it after 4-5 weeks cure, but it will be milder after a longer cure so don't throw it away if you don't like it straight away. Try it again at 3 months, then six months to see what you think of the recipe over time.
 
You can certainly make a high OO recipe. I'm one who doesn't like high OO but I would do your shea recipe personally. High OO recipes need a longer cure. I would also drop your CO to 20-25%. too much CO can be drying to many. I don't have a problem and I've got older skin. If you're not opposed to and can get lard I highly recommend using lard. It makes a gentle soap and it's great.

Either way, give it a try and see how you like it.
 
Thank you to mods moving this thread, I had completely missed this section of the forum!

I thought most would recommend the lower CO recipe, and I was leaning towards it. Mostly hesitant because I feel like I've already spent too much on it this month as I had to buy everything I need for equipment. Could have gone for makeshift options but wouldn't have saved much as I needed a stick blender and new scale for it.
I ordered some shea butter anyway to try, only making a small batch so low cost anyways on ingredients. Thank you guys for the input, I hope making soap will be worth it!
 
Back
Top