I have used
Bombshell
Sweet Pea
Eternity
possibly a few others, at the time I ordered they were having a good price on Lye. Two of the FO were nice. The Sweet Pea is a good Bath Body Works dupe -- compare it to be the same as NG. The Bombshell I can't compare to anything else, since I have never seen or purchased it elsewhere. However, Bombshell is AMAZING! The Eternity I put in a batch of lotion bars & the scent was lost.
Their oils were shipped in brown glass bottles, not plastic like many of the discount suppliers. Overall I was pleased & will prob order the bombshell again. Just wish it was cheaper!!!